Atlas Shrugged: The Mocking

Monday, April 28, 2008

Sir John Bull----

John Derbyshire ticks off his readers by dissing Expelled. To explain, he extols the virtues of the scientific method, that crowning achievement of Western Civilization. Take it away, Derb. We don't want to miss a single word.

In any case, I am not reviewing the movie. What I am doing is, heaping
well-justified abuse on the heads of people who, for "sentimental qualms" and
from a position of ignorance, trash scientific method, the greatest achievement
of our civilization.
And uniquely of our civilization. A mature scientific
theory is as much a glory of our civilization as is a cathedral or a university;
and it is uniquely of ours. Other civilizations had temples, universities,
systems of government, literature, philosophy; but only we of the West came up
with scientific method, and the whole world owes the innumerable fruits of that
method to us.
I am a huge fan of Western civilization. Thus, when
people — well-educated people, who ought to set an example for the
general — sneer at and spit on these majestic creations of the human
intellect, I get mad. They are taking sides with barbarism. They ought to be
ashamed of themselves.


Say, Derb, didn't an Arab, Ibn al-Haytham, invent the scientific method?

And he's the smart one.

3 comments:

zeppo said...

Hey, it's the thought that counts, and on this one, I am right there with him. I've written a number of posts at my place about this topic. Willfull ignorance and the idea that opinions and the conclusions arrived at using the scientific method are the same thing just bug the crap out of me. Any little bit helps, even if he did get the source really wrong.

aimai said...

Derbyshire is occasionally right. I have to say it. But it makes me gag.

aimai

Susan of Texas said...

Lol. I do enjoy seeing him fight with the theists at the Corner. He has no problem calling them on their stupider excesses.

He's revolting, though, to be sure. Even when he gets it right he gets it wrong. People like Derbyshire will praise the scientific menthod one second and call all Arabs scum the next.