More Jonah The Philosopher:
This may sound like the usual conservative caterwauling about social unraveling and balkanization. But it isn’t.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
"What I tell you three times is true."
Atlas Shrugged: The Mocking
E-Mail Address
Blogroll
- A Tiny Revolution
- Angry Bear
- Barking Rabbits
- Big Bad Bald Bastard
- Blckdgrd
- Bonddad Blog
- Brilliant At Breakfast
- Buck Naked Politics
- Calculated Risk
- Charles Pierce
- Clusterfuck Nation
- Corrente
- Crooked Timber
- Dennis Perrin
- Doghouse Riley
- Donkey Punch
- Empire Burlesque
- Exercise in Futility
- Fire Megan McArdle
- Freedom Rider
- Gall And Gumption
- Glenn Greenwald
- House of Substance
- Hullabaloo
- Hyperbole and a Half
- I Don't Like You Either
- If I Ran The Zoo
- Informed Comment
- Instaputz
- Just Another Blog (From L.A.)
- Last Left Turn Before Hooterville
- No More Mister Nice Blog
- Notes From Underground
- Once Upon A Time
- Pen-Elayne
- Prairie Weather
- Pruning Shears
- Roger Ailes
- Sadly, No!
- Sarah, Proud and Tall
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- TBogg
- The Inverse Square Blog
- The Plutocracy Files
- The Rolled Up Newspaper
- The Sideshow
- Think Progress
- Vagabond Scholar
- Whiskey Fire
- William K. Wolfrum Chronicles
- World-O-Crap
- alicublog
- ifthethunderdontgetya™³²®©
- rightwingsnarkle
Serials
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(343)
-
▼
December
(48)
- Would It Kill You To Stay Out Of My Vagina?
- Republicans Help Save (Bad) Marriages
- Lisa Schiffren Is So Much Fun
- Such a Nice Man
- The Mona Charen Marriage Laws
- Angels and Minister of Grace Defend Us!
- Don't Say Another Word
- The Best and Brightest
- Oy, The Pain: Your Daily Megan McArdle
- The Viagra Pundit Strikes Again; Lying Freak Discu...
- McArdle For Rent; Attic Empty, Basement Full of It
- Jonah Goldberg is Beneath Contempt
- Peace on Earth, Good Will Towards Men
- Shorter Jonah Goldberg
- Less Tall Megan, Too Busy To Post Version
- Small Note, Big Topic
- A Match Made in Heaven
- Breaking! Porn Stalks Land; Males At Risk!
- The Peaceful Life of the Battered Child
- Back Tonight
- Viva Zapato
- Christmas Shopping List!
- Let's Read Some Stupid
- Merry Christmas!
- Who Could Have Known?
- McArdle Says: No Deflation
- Christmas Comes Early
- Spite and Consequence
- I Need To Know
- Mazel Tov!
- A Small Announcement
- Get Out Of Here!
- Snark!
- Sucks To Be You
- Flotsam & Jetsam
- Disgusting Hack Strikes Again
- The League of Extraordinary Bloggers
- A Statistics-Based Disagreement Between Professionals
- No Mas, Por Favor
- Cornucopia
- Are You Ready To Be Strong?
- Nature Versus, Uh, Nature
- Invisible Megan
- Mining For Nuggets
- Brief Notes
- Followers
- The Rewards of Failure
- Greed or Laziness?
-
▼
December
(48)
6 comments:
I can't believe I actually made it through part of a Jonah column.
"Series such as Dexter, House, and countless others have elevated egomania, self-absorption, and narcissism to admirable character traits."
Right. Because "admirable" is the first word that comes to mind when I think of serial killers and grumpy, pill-popping doctors. Goldberg is such an idiot. His observations on culture are completely insipid and useless.
He's so wrong it's easy to see he's just phoning it in. What a life, huh?
Some say she's from Mars
or one of the seven stars
that shine after 3:30 in the morning...
WELL, SHE ISN'T!!!
--Planet Claire, B-52s
Hmm. Jonah Goldberg and Fred Schneider, post-punk dance-party soulmates. Who knew?
"Series such as Dexter, House, and countless others have elevated egomania, self-absorption, and narcissism to admirable character traits."
What. a. dip.
What is it Roy Edroso calls it? Kulturkampf? Right wing philistines somehow believing that the main purpose of art is the promotion of "values."
Worse, they have such a juvenile appreciation of literature and drama that they believe the main character in any fiction must always be the "hero," and it stands to reason (in their eyes) that the writer "admires" all the hero's characteristics. It's like they never heard of the concept of the "anti-hero," where, if there's any conscious promoting going on, it's the writer's profound belief in things CONTRARY to the main character's (professed) values.
The thing about House is that he is in a constant struggle against softer, more "dangerous" emotions and beliefs. His strongest characterological drive is toward Truth at all costs, and the way this otherwise "admirable" quality plays out against his arrogant dismissal of other aspects of Being Human is what drives most of the drama. It's fucking brilliant. And dimwits like Jonah can't begin to grasp it because they think the narrative is CELEBRATING House's approach to life.
No, it's not even merely dimwitted...it's some other word, some other worse adjective that I can't even think of, maybe because what Jonah is is SO awful we don't actually have coherent words to describe it.
So maybe we'll have to resort to ART.
Maybe Philistine is a good word for his type. I looked it up and wikipedia has a J.D. Salinger quote: "A person deprived, for life, of any understanding or taste for the main current of poetry that flows through things, all things."
And it also says, [The Phoenicians'] boutique culture could not withstand the Assyrian and later Babylonian expansions into Canaan, however – after which they disappeared as a cohesive cultural group."
The insulated world they hope to live in is truly a little hothouse culture. They won't be able to survive without the backing of a wealthy elite, because they certainly can't survive on their merits. Who wants propaganda, which is predictable by definition, when they could have originality and surprise, which only true art can achieve?
Love the Salinger quote. Thanks for that.
Who wants propaganda, which is predictable by definition, when they could have originality and surprise, which only true art can achieve?
Who indeed? Actually, it's clear that there is an audience for predictable fiction (at least), and it seems to consist of fearful people who HATE to be surprised.
Conservatives, by definition.
Post a Comment