Atlas Shrugged: The Mocking

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Compare and Contrast.

Let's compare and contrast Megan's attitude towards the poor and the rich. That's always fun.

The Poor:
On the other hand, expanding jobless claims to 52 weeks seems like a no brainer--not because it's awesome stimulus, but because it would be nice if people who can't find jobs in a severe economic contraction don't have to take up a second career as bank robbers.


The Rich:
Bankers are not criminals. As a class, they are exactly as self-interested, self-destructive, and short-sighted as other classes of people that liberals want less highly regulated, such as unions and community organizers. I don't view the purpose of regulation as punishment, or protection against a malevolent class. I view it as an attempt to make our institutions more effectively channel self-interest into collectively welfare-enhancing activity. Thus you can see why I might be somewhat uncomfortable with those who seem to view the crisis as an exciting opportunity to put those uppity bankers back in their place.


Megan assumes bankers are honest and poor people are dishonest. This fits in nicely with her theory that only rich people can be moral, because people are only moral if it benefits them. That may be Megan's belief, but it's not everyone else's.

It's so tiresome to have to constantly fight against immoral, shallow people. Why don't they just stick to little jobs that don't harm anyone, instead of trying to swim with sharks?

A person with such poor ethics and judgement should not be advising others about money.

Monday, October 20, 2008

Feeding Frenzy

The Corner is in a frenzy, churning out post after post about the media's preferential treatment of Obama, a simple fact in their circular world.

Jonah Goldberg: If the media were more objective, we’d be hearing a lot more about the racism at the heart of the Democratic Party. (Imagine if the black nominee this year were a Republican!) But such objectivity would cause too much cognitive dissonance for a press corps that defines “racist” as shorthand for Republican and sees itself as the publicity arm of the Obama campaign.

Jonah Goldberg: To listen to most MSM commentators and analysts, you'd think Obama's problem with racist voters is some how the Republican Party's fault. Guess what? Republicans (including racist Republicans) are going to vote for the Republican.

Andy McCarthy: [...T]he always terrific Scott Johnson has nice things to say at Powerline, including wondering aloud (as has our friend John Podhoretz at Commentary) why the mainstream media has ignored the book.

Mark Steyn: Re Joe the Plumber, if I hear another bigshot media correspondent stating that Joe's feeble earnings mean he would not pay more tax under King Barack the Wealth-Spreader and thus has nothing to complain about, I'll pull over, rip the radio out, and stomp it into the shoulder, as Frank Sinatra is said to have done the fifth time he heard "Light My Fire" on a road trip from Palm Springs to Los Angeles.

Byron York: I have a new story up about John McCain's rally Saturday in Woodbridge, Virginia. You've heard all that talk about how angry and hate-filled such gatherings are. And I have to say, there was some anger at the Woodbridge event, but it wasn't, as some erroneous reports from other McCain rallies have suggested, directed at Barack Obama. It was directed at the press. That morning, the New York Times had published a thin and mean-spirited front-page story on Cindy McCain (more on that later), and many in the crowd were still angry over the media's treatment of Joe the Plumber.

Re: Confused Broadcasting System [Mark Steyn]
Attention, crack CBS News Fact Check Unit! The man in this picture claiming to be a Berliner is, in fact, from Massachusetts. Furthermore, as a citizen of the United States, he is not eligible to vote in Berlin municipal elections.

Mark Steyn: Last post of the day, first post of the day. Oh, dear, I hope I haven't chased the last three conservative pundits away to The Plank or The Atlantic. Re Joe*, Jim (Treacher) puts it this way:

The whole "He's not a licensed plumber!" non sequitur is really fantastic. So, if you happen to be standing in front of Obama when he publicly reveals his socialism, what does the media do? Demands to see your papers. That's just delicious, is what that is.


Mark Steyn: Back in the glory days of the 2000 New Hampshire primary, his media buddies used to translate "old and cranky" as "maverick", "feisty", and so forth. But let that pass.

And the incessant sniping of conservative pundits is having an effect in the so-called real world. From The Washington Post:

"No, I'm not mad, I'm pissed," said Joan Schmitz, who owns a plumbing company here. She said she was frustrated with polls showing Obama surging, McCain's performance in a Tuesday night debate, Obama himself, the media, and the liberal group ACORN, which she said was registering voters fraudulently.

Noting Obama's connections with Ayers, she said that "if it was a Republican, it would be nonstop," referring to what she said was the media ignoring the controversial acquaintance.

"I can't stand to look at him, I don't trust him. I don't like the circle of friends he keeps, I don't like his policies," Schmitz said of Obama. "I'm pissed off by it. I'm beyond mad. How is he climbing up in the polls?"

On the way into the event, the Republican Party of Wisconsin handed out fliers reading "Your Vote Is Being Stolen," an anti-ACORN leaflet that concluded, "Why is vote fraud allowed? Vote fraud is allowed since it benefits Democrats."

The crowd showed equal disdain for the media, fueled by comments from Palin, who encouraged the Republican supporters to take the campaign's message around the media. "I can't pick a fight with those who buy ink by the barrel," she said. "It's dangerous territory whenever I suggest the mainstream media isn't asking all the questions."

That message was clearly shared among the crowd. Mike Payne, who traveled from Madison, Wis., for the rally, rejected the idea that McCain's supporters are angry, preferring to use the word "frustrated."

"It might have something to do with you guys," he told a reporter.

"It's not anger at all. It's frustration. There's millions of people around the country that think like we do. You guys refuse to acknowledge that, and you insult our intelligence by misreporting the information. You are treating [Obama] like he's Britney Spears and covering him like he's Paris Hilton, instead of the next president of the United States, potentially."

McCain advisers dismissed the crowd's angry tone as an exception and not representative of most of the campaign's events. And they noted that those gathered seemed most upset by the media's handling of the contest, and simply wanted McCain to be more aggressive.


Finally McCain was embarrassed often enough in public to tone down his supporters, but Palin doesn't have McCain's (tenuous) control. If the McCains and Palins will continue to avoid the media, the media will feel free to print drivel like this article on Cindy McCain. And it will continue to print articles like the Post article.

It's a vicious circle, with the weasels at the Corner biting and snarling at the foxes in the media. There's a small entertainment value in watching the fur fly, but it would be really nice if people didn't try to incite hate during difficult times.

Judge Sarah--Jesus Didn't Mean *Me*

Via Think Progress:

PALIN: [I]n my own, state, I have voted along with the vast majority of Alaskans who had the opportunity to vote to amend our Constitution defining marriage as between one man and one woman. I wish on a federal level that that’s where we would go because I don’t support gay marriage. I’m not going to be out there judging individuals, sitting in a seat of judgment telling what they can and can’t do, should and should not do.

You just did. You voted to tell gays that they can't marry because you have judged them ineligible. Saying "I'm not judging." when you quite clearly are judging doesn't change anything. It just shows you're a liar as well as a bigot and bad Christian.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

A Little Knowledge

It's a shame Megan McArdle doesn't work on the weekends. She might be missing this Big Picture post about her blogginghead video with Dan Drezner:


This is political, opinion driven debate. It is empty and foolish rhetoric that
generates heat but no light. As opposed to a discussion driven by, oh, I don't
know, let's say "facts and data?" It contributes nothing of value in terms
of identifying what actually happened. The focus is not on what went wrong, and
what can we do to fix it. Rather, its how the party in charge takes the blame,
and therefore the acceptance level of their ideology goes down.

Imagine after a jumbo jet goes down, and someone from the FAA said "We won't bother looking for the black box, we don't play the blame game around here." They would be fired immediately, and then tarred and feathered by the victims families.

Intelligent societies seek to asses blame not for political reasons, but
to avoid future jets from tumbling out of the sky again. In the current
situation, we want to know why this happened, what errors were made, and how we
can avoid it in the future.

There is also an element of cognitive dissonance to the discussion. Rather than look at the factual pattern of changes to the regulatory environment (see these comments in The Economist), it was merely a coincidence of the party in power getting the blame. Why do I suspect that if Al Gore was President, these two would not be discussing the mere coincidence of which party had the White House?

This is a similar approach that has given us one of the dumbest phrases in the
English language: "The Blame Game." (as in "well, I am not going to play the blame game).

My beef is not political, its evidentiary: There are no facts shown, no regulatory historical record dissected, no comprehension of what actually occurred -- just how to duck resposibility. This is why I hate ideologues, politics, and even political discussions of ideology -- it leads to smart people saying dumb things. Cognitive dissonance will do that to you.

So will stupidity. It's so nice to see someone else do the heavy lifting, though. I'm hampered by my lack of knowledge of economics; the development of personality and how it affects the choices one makes is my field of interest. But I read widely, so I also found this:



The Federal Bureau of Investigation is struggling to find enough agents and resources to investigate criminal wrongdoing tied to the country’s economic crisis, according to current and former bureau officials.
...
The pressure on the F.B.I. has recently increased with the disclosure of
criminal investigations into some of the largest players in the financial
collapse, including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The F.B.I. is planning to double the number of agents working financial crimes by reassigning several hundred agents amid a mood of national alarm.


So much for McArdle's plea that bankers aren't crooks; they're just drawn that way.

And for some reason I thought of McArdle when I saw this article about Andrew Lahde's farewell to the hedge fund troops.

Andrew Lahde, the hedge-fund manager who quit after posting an 870 percent gain last year, said farewell to clients in a letter that thanks stupid traders for making him rich and ends with a plea to legalize marijuana.

Lahde, head of Santa Monica, California-based Lahde Capital Management LLC, told investors last month he was returning their cash because the risk of using credit derivatives -- his means of betting on the falling value of bonds and loans, including subprime mortgages -- was too risky given the weakness of the banks he was trading with.

``I was in this game for money,'' Lahde, 37, wrote in a two-page letter today in which he said he had come to hate the hedge-fund business. ``The low-hanging fruit, i.e. idiots whose parents paid for prep school, Yale and then the Harvard MBA, was there for the taking. These people who were (often) truly not worthy of the education they received (or supposedly received) rose to the top of companies such as AIG, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers and all levels of our government.

``All of this behavior supporting the Aristocracy, only ended up making it easier for me to find people stupid enough to take the other sides of my trades. God Bless America.''


Authoritarians can be depended upon to mindlessly support the Aristocracy at all times, no matter what it might cost them. Afterward they look up to the sky and say, "Why me? What happened? Who will lead me now? Who do I blame?"

It sure won't be themselves.

The Devil's Bargain

Billmon explores the "new stabbed-in-the-back myth," the Limbaughs call Obama a socialist, and Jonah Goldberg makes his bones by calling liberals fascist. The Authoritarians are indulging in a frenzy of fear and loathing, for the impossible is about to come true: The Authoritarian Leaders are going to lose.

How can this be? they ask themselves. Obama is one of those. He's a liberal, and liberals don't follow the rules. That's why they can't be trusted. The rules say that if you are obedient, you'll be rewarded. Your parents will love you and God will favor you and your country will be great and strong. If you aren't obedient, your parents will be mad at you and God will punish you and you won't be safe anymore. The Bad Guys will get you. It's the same old devil's bargain; safety for freedom. When you don't feel safe you give up freedom, but it's weak to give up freedom, so you have to shout Freedom! Freedom! over and over to convince yourself that you still have it. You don't really want it--you just gave it up, remember?--but it makes you feel weak to realize that you want safety so very badly. So you just pretend instead, and shout louder. And just in case someone points out the obvious, that you are afraid and embracing fascism to chase away that fear, you'll call them fascists first.

Just in case.

The Republicans gutted the treasury and trashed the economy and therefore will lose the election. But Authoritarians are incapable of learning from experience, since they can't question anyone or anything. They will lash out in anger instead. It should not be tolerated for one minute. Authoritarians' fears must be exposed for what they are; a desire to be controlled and restrained, to gain the illusion of safety. They need it to survive. We don't.

Friday, October 17, 2008

Megan Explains Herself: The Explaining.

Pull up a chair, grab a cup of coffee, and smoke 'em if you got 'em. It's time to visit Megan's Playhouse. This post deserves a good, hard frisking, but like everyone else this is a part-time gig for me, and the highlights will have to suffice.

First Megan pins her ire on poor Brian Beutler. Evidently he has gone from being her blogger friend whose injury shocked her to simply another liberal blogger. And what have those naughty liberal blogs been up to?

Several liberal blogs are chortling over this statement I made early in the
year: [etc. etc.]

They "chortled"? There was "chortling"? The merry sounds of chortle were heard through the land? That literary noise must have really discomforted Megan, so, being a empathetic liberal, I did a little search* for anyone who could be laughing at her. I found four sites that laugh or have laughed at Megan, but at the time of her post only two blogs mentioned the "explaining" post; mine and Beutler's. Since I doubt Megan reads this blog, her "several" liberal blogs is really the aforementioned one blog. One blog, that sent her on an orgy of explaining and excusing. Just one. (Has Megan considered teaching? You need a thick skin there too, but at least there isn't a permanet record of one's overreactions.)

And then the insults begin, from the self-professed model of civility named Megan.

This is what comes from not reading economics commentators besides Paul Krugman.

The belief that Paul Krugman is some sort of singularly talented
prognosticator on matters of policy and the economy is almost entirely found
among people who do not spend a lot of time reading the financial press, and
also, have forgotten the many concerns he expressed that did not come to pass.

I do not think it is possible to regularly read those [financial]
publications and reasonably sustain the belief that Paul Krugman has been
uniquely, or even especially, prescient about current conditions. That's no slam
on Krugman. It's a slam on people who are unaware that there are really quite a
lot of smart people out there writing about the economic issues of the day.


So much for the gullible fools who think Krugman is All That. Now, Krugman himself. Do you think he's Nobel material? You fool, you! Megan has plenty to say to help you understand that Krugman isn't so special after all, no matter what everyone says.

Almost every commenter who is not named David Lereah both recognized that we
were in a housing bubble, and expected that when the housing bubble popped, the
economic results would be ugly.

So the idea that Krugman has somehow won
one for the team by predicting something that
libertarian/conservative/free-market commentators didn't see coming is either
misinformed, or lunatic. We all saw the problems with the housing bubble; most
of us thought a recession was getting pretty likely, given America's terrific
overextension of its consumption, the falling housing market, rising commodity
prices, and the simple fact that the longer you've gone without a recession, the
more likely you are to get into one soon.

The belief that Paul Krugman
is some sort of singularly talented prognosticator on matters of policy and the
economy is almost entirely found among people who do not spend a lot of time
reading the financial press, and also, have forgotten the many concerns he
expressed that did not come to pass.

Krugman is a great popularizer of
economics, but his writing is not filled with unique insights that cannot be
gleaned elsewhere.

See, he just thought and said what everyone else thought and said. Nothing special about that.

In fact, Megan herself was frequently just as smart as Krugman! Here is where I realized that I've constantly underestimated Megan McArdle. I thought that becasue she isn't very smart that she can't do smart things. Nothing is further from the truth. You don't need brains to be cunning, you just need a lot of self-interest and a little ruthlessness. I thought Megan couldn't manage to ride the coattails of a man she's often denegrated, but watch carefully what she does here:

What I--and, as far as I know, Paul Krugman--did not expect was the magnitude or
the direction of the problems it would cause. We expected first, consumption
contraction from a reversal of something known as the "wealth effect"--when
assets appreciate, people feel richer, so they spend more; they also sometimes
borrow against the current or future value of those assets.

Did you catch that? It was quite subtle.

What I--and, as far as I know, Paul Krugman--did not expect was the magnitude or
the direction of the problems it would cause. We


There! Megan said she didn't know what Krugman expected, but as far as she knew he agreed with her. Then she jumps straight to "We." Beautiful! I'll give that a 9.4, losing only a fraction of a point for her tactic's inevitible failure.

But wait, there's more!

We also expected that it would hurt bank balance sheets, which would mean
retrenchment and therefore a slowdown in lending to other areas. I, and possibly
Krugman--I don't really have time to comb through every column he's ever written
right now--further expected that it would have deleterious effects on the
government fiscal picture, especially in bubbly areas. And, of course, we
expected that the eventual decline in the construction boom would show up in
GDP, since construction is a major component.

Mind you, she doesn't have time to comb through every column of his. It's not like it's her job, or something.

Megan than throws in a few mistakes for the sake of not looking like an idiot, since her old posts keep popping up, accompanied by more liberal chortling.

What I--and, as far as I know, Paul Krugman--did not expect was the magnitude or
the direction of the problems it would cause.

But I did not foresee how
tightly coupled our financial system would prove to be. I didn't see how far the
problems would spread--I didn't even expect the magnitude of the crackdown in
commercial real estate lending, much less the generalized credit freeze.
Neither, AFAIK, did Paul Krugman. And one of the areas that we were both very
concerned about, the decline of the wealth effect, has proven to be relatively
much less important than expected.

You see, neither of them were 100% right, so they're even, they're equals. Almost.

Krugman also thought we might be about to get into a recession several earlier
times, when I was more skeptical; in that sense, I called it better than he did.
My care about calling a recession earlier in the year was not because I thought
the economy was in fine fettle. Rather, it was because Britain had, against all
theory, dodged a recession despite a popping housing bubble even more impressive
than ours. This even though they'd gone more than a decade without one. Having
watched the British economy in my professional capacity for most of the current
decade, I'd seen it declared on the verge of recession multiple times by various
commenters, for what seemed like good and sound reasons; nonetheless, it never
quite went there. This made me somewhat cautious about proclaiming that a recession was inevitable based on our fundamentals.

Megan is even more right than the sometimes wrong Nobel prize winner.

You know what's next.

I know I saw that recession around here somewhere . . .
31 Jul 2008 11:56 am
The economy grew at 1.9% last quarter. Two thoughts.
First, the American economy is simply amazingly resilient--1.9% is cause for
exultant celebration in a lot of European finance ministries. And second, Barack
Obama's campaign team is probably doing some serious rethinking this morning.

And--

I took some flak on liberal blogs for pointing out that Paul Krugman has
been the voice of doom on the economy for nigh on a decade. But there was good
reason to think that there might be a recession, my critics cried.
Here's the problem. What's the one time that Paul Krugman didn't forecast a recession? That would be when we actually had a recession. It just wasn't a recession that could be blamed
on George Bush.

And--

Paul Krugman is voting for doom. It's worth keeping in mind, however, that Paul Krugman has
predicted eight of the last none recessions under the Bush administration.
I think it's obvious we're in a slowdown, and a recession seems likely-ish, but
Britain's skirted recession for over a decade now, so I can't be too
fatalistic.


Clearly McArdle thought Krugman was both wrong and too ideological to see the "truth" anyway. Finally, Megan ends with a quotable sop to Krugman's reputation and skill. It's quite the performance. Megan would be perfect for Fox TV, to provide explanations to their viewers on how the Democrats brought about the recession by being right for the wrong reason.



*I checked technorati and google, about five pages in each. Heh, and I found this.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Megan Explains Herself

This post deserves careful, loving treatment. It deserves to have a spa day all for its very own, where its words can be painted and polished, and its little face given a mud bath. It's so very sweet and precious you just want to hug it.

Go, read it. You know you want to, even if you feel naughty afterwards.

Megan Discusses Regulation

Megan McArdle's meltdown continues apace, as McArdle warns us against regulation, again. For her first warning, McArdle pulls out a strawman puppet, sets it on her knee, and has it spout a dire warning towards imaginary people lusting for revenge against the cruel, greedy capitalist bankers.

Her second warning is that regulation can do more damage than good, and gives mark-to-market accounting as an example. Mark-to-market forces transparency on businesses, which is desirable because the credit freeze is largely caused by the mistrust banks feel towards each other right now. Nobody knows exactly how much banks have lost, and how much money they have left. Not everyone thinks mark-to-market is bad at this point. Via Calculated Risk:

"Suspending mark-to-market accounting, in essence, suspends reality."Beth
Brooke, global vice chair at Ernst & Young LLP, WSJ, Sept 30,
2008


"Blaming fair-value accounting for the credit crisis is a lot like going to
a doctor for a diagnosis and then blaming him for telling you that you are
sick."analyst Dane Mott, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Bloomberg

"Suspending the mark-to-market prices is the most irresponsible thing to
do. Accounting does not make corporate earnings or balance sheets more volatile.
Accounting just increases the transparency of volatility in earnings."Diane
Garnick, Invesco Ltd., Bloomberg

But hey, Megan's been right so far, she's probably right here too.

Megan's Good Advice

Bloomberg, Via Calculated Risk:


Standard & Poor's said it may downgrade $280.1 billion of Alt-A
mortgage securities, the most that the ratings company has identified in a
single announcement for bonds backed by the loans. The debt may be cut in part
because S&P has boosted estimates for losses on each foreclosure on Alt-A
loans with at least five years of fixed rates to 40 percent, from 35 percent
...``There has been a persistent rise in the level of delinquencies among the
Alt-A mortgage loans supporting these transactions,'' S&P analysts Scott
Davey and Ernestine Warner said in the statement.


Megan McArdle:

4 August, 2008--"Housing: Are More and Worse Defaults To Come?" The New York Times says possibly, thanks to Alt-A loans that
had generous teaser rates. Those borrowers will take longer to get themselves in
trouble, but without rising home prices, eventually they, too, will find
themselves under water.

I'm a little more skeptical than the Times.
Option arms and other exploding loans became popular in 2005 and 2006, thanks to
rising home prices. But Alt-A buyers qualified for longer teaser periods than
subprime borrowers--5 to 7 years instead of 2 to 3. That means that those
defaults won't start coming until 2010 at the earliest. By that time, economic
growth should be picking up, and (at the rate Ben Bernanke is going, anyway)
inflation will have eased some of the pain of their loans, even in a weak
housing market. Analysts generally expect housing declines to be three years
from peak to trough, so we're riding out the worst of it right now--at least, if
history is any guide.

Moreover, Alt-A buyers have more to lose, in terms
of their credit rating, and are generally a little more firmly rooted in the
American homeownership culture than those borrowing at subprime rates. I'd
expect them to fight a lot harder to hold onto their homes, and their ratings,
than the subprime borrowers--85% of whom, remember, are still paying their loans
on time.

11 August, 2008--After every bubble, there's generally a sort of an
anti-bubble--when analysts start looking for reasons that this is, like, the
worst crisis ever. The worries about Alt-A mortgages seem to me to be
largely part of this fever. "Everything in the future will be exactly like
everything that just happened" is what got us into this mess in the first place
. . .


I thought I'd be too worried to smile when the crash hit, but McArdle is the comedy gift that never stops.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Oh, Megan!

I have to run so this will be too short. This is working out far better than I thought. Instead of finding valid academic reasons to support her (wrong) views, Megan is now attacking instead. Yeah, sure, maybe Krugman and Roubini were right, but were they right for the right reasons? Huh? Huh? Or were they "monkeys throwing darts" and finally getting a bulls-eye?

Too funny.

The Corner Has Died and Its Corpse Is Stinking Up the Joint

I haven't heard of this Corner writer before. He has a fine career in wingnuttery ahead of him.

Ah, via Google I see he's a university professor. (Why is the right always whining about liberal academia?)

Advice to McCain [John J. Pitney, Jr.]

What demeanor should McCain display tonight? Angry doesn't
work. Solemn doesn't work. ake-smiley doesn't work. Instead, McCain
should go back to his roots and unleash his inner smart-aleck. If Obama
accuses him of being erratic in a crisis, he should say: "So I'm erotic in a
crisis? Who knew?"

This approach has a couple of advantages. First, it enables McCain to
show the more appealing side of his personality. Second, it throws Obama
off his game. His handlers have surely anticipated every possible attack line
about Ayers and Wright. And as a good liberal, he's waiting for the chance
to say, "Have you left no sense of decency?" But he'd be hard put to defend
against ridicule. The One can't handle the jokes.

So to get ready for the debate, McCain should lay aside the notes, crack
open a beer, and watch Animal House.


That's--really bad advice. (Although the idea of McCain going nuts on teevee is a matter of when, not if.)

Will You Come To Tea?

Miss Megan McArdle's irrelevance continues, as she indulges in one of her favorite themes; how the hoi polloi should not even try to go to college, and become useful service people instead. When the lady of the manor finishes discussing the servant problem, she moves on to the economy. She has filmed an interesting conversation she and her good friend Dan Drezner had in the drawing room. They discussed "the economy, regulation, and the future of the Republican Party." One could listen in, but one surmises there will be little to learn, and no surprises. Finally Miss McArdle tosses a bon mot into the little crowd of admirers that gathers around her, who titter and eagerly examine her merry observations, while she saunters off to enjoy her day.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Breaking! Megan not Dead!

After copious review and study, and weeks spent coughing delicately into her handkerchief, Megan McArdle is back, doing what she does best--posting quotes and restating their main idea. All that synthesis will pop up later, I'm sure.

It's a sort of interesting quandary for libertarians, and indeed most proponents of regulation, who want the government to enhance transparency. In this case, the government is specifically fighting to keep the market from getting information about whose balance sheets are shakiest. And I'm not sure they're wrong.
Since Megan has a difficult time understanding human actions, I'll point it out for her. Her ideas have been proven problematic, and idle musings on that "interesting quandary" make her look even less serious than usual. Fortunately her boss doesn't seem to notice whether or not she's alive, let alone know what she writes.

Speaking of pop, McArdle writes an extremely gracious congratulations to Paul Krugman, the "populizer" of "popular work" "such as Pop Internationalism." Except she can't actually bring herself to congratulate him.

But though the timing may have been political, the prize is well deserved,
indeed overdue, as plenty of other commenters have noted. I would offer my
congratulations if I thought that the good professor cared to get them.
What does a temple priestess do after her gods are no longer worshipped? The invisible hand of the agora isn't always kind.

Monday, October 13, 2008

Chicago Boyz and Girlz

Congratulations to Paul Krugman, Nobel prize winner! (Yes I still disagree about the bailout.)

Besides the pleasure of seeing a sane man praised and vindicated, there is the pleasure of seeing the not-so-sane debunked. Moon Of Alabama says:

After years of favoring 'Chicago economists', who laid the grounds for the
current disaster, the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences finally seems to change
course.
Signs of the times?


And the sign says "Dead End."

Who could have imagined that Wall Street, of all places, could be overcome by greed and love of money and power? That the invisible hand of the market was really the imaginary hand of the market? That Megan McArdle, graduate of the Universiy of Chicago and fervent booster of Milton Friedman, could be--gasp!--wrong?

You can thank Milton Friedman for the fact that our central banks no longer
hand us double-digit inflation in a fruitless quest for permanently higher
output levels. While his work has since been refined, and his push for quantity
targeting has largely been abandoned, he remains central to modern monetary
policy. His permanent income hypothesis has made similar contributions to
consumption theory. His students have also expanded the boundaries of human
knowlege in significant ways, particularly Gary Becker, another Nobel-prize
winner.

Unlike other popularisers, such as Paul Krugman, whose best popular work
(such as Pop Internationalism) focused on his own field, what Mr Friedman is
known for within the academy is completely different from what has made him
famous outside it, which is possibly why liberals tend to classify him with Mr
Galbraith. Mr Friedman has done more than possibly any other economist to
advance the cause of free markets. But that is not his only contribution;
perhaps it is not even his largest. Anyone who would compare the Nobel
prize-winner to JKG as an economist can only have a gaping hole in their
economic education.


I just thought it would be funny to reprint that.

Hee.

When over 100 University of Chicago professors revolted at the idea of a Milton Friedman Institute on campus, McArdle wrote:

Over 100 Chicago professors proudly sign
a letter
declaring their ignorance of economics:

[...]

This
[letter] from a University that has cultivated a reputation as one of the most
intellectually rigorous campuses in the country. I'm tempted to weep.

[...]

[...T]heir assessment of the effects of the "neoliberal global order"
is forehead slapping, head shaking, did-they-really-say that? stupid.

[...]

The last paragraph makes these eminent professors seem, to
put it charitably, not quite bright.

[...]

It's foolish to get
enraged at these powerless twits. But someone has to writhe in shame at this
folly, and clearly, their intellects aren't up to the task.


There's lots more, and it's great to read. McArdle's so much fun when she actually gets passionate about something, such as her reputation or status. First Bush, then Greenspan, and now Freidman et al. I don't know how history will assess these events, but right now McArdle might want to take the sage advice of one George Costanza: If you have an impulse, do and say the opposite of what you would usually do.

Sunday, October 12, 2008

For the Love of God

So deluded. So very, very deluded.

Getting Ahead of Themselves [Kathryn Jean Lopez]

Thank you, Speaker Pelosi, for this preview
of life if there's a President Obama:

WASHINGTON (AP) - After consulting with Barack Obama, Democratic leaders are likely to call Congress back to work after the election in hopes of passing legislation that would include extended jobless benefits, money for food stamps and possibly a tax rebate, officials said Saturday.

The bill's total cost could reach $150 billion, these officials said.

The officials stressed that no final decisions have been made. They spoke on condition of anonymity, saying they did not want to pre-empt a formal announcement. House Democrats have announced plans for an economic forum on Monday "to help Congress develop an economic recovery plan that focuses on creating jobs and strengthening our economy."
Expect big-governemtn goodies — money for nothing and your socialism for "free" — until a Repblican is looked to try to undo it all in four.

Thanks to this preview, Americans should be taking a second look. Will they? Wake up! Good morning! There's still an election going on. Contrary to Obama-Pelosi-Reid posturing, it ain't over yet.

Forget the typos; I do that myself, although nobody's paying me to be an editor and go on teevee. I won't even bother to point out the hypocrisy, the obliviousness. I just want to ask: Is this woman let out without a keeper? Does Nanny follow her from her parents' house to the office to the airport, and hang a tag on her when she's travelling?

Does she pay taxes, read grown-up newspapers, make love, cook meals, bully sexist service people? Or does she float from condo to taxi to airplane to office, skimming the surface of the world like a waterbug on a pond?

Saturday, October 11, 2008

Megan, With a Bullet

Why do I have the feeling Megan McArdle is feverishly pouring through her old textbooks to find a way to mitigate how Alan Greenspan, Milton Freeman, and Wall Street were so very wrong?

K-Lo Goes To Confession

VII Mission: Impossible

K-Lo: Bless me Father for I have sinned. It has been three days, ten hours, six minutes and forty-nine--fifty--fifty-one---.

Father: (interrupts) Do you have a new watch, Kathryn Jean?

K-Lo: Yes, Father. My father gave it to me for my birthday. It has a stopwatch and a calendar and Mary's face is on the dial. Look, her arms are the hands; one is holding Baby Jesus and the other is holding an American Flag. See, it looks like she's waving it when it moves.

Father: That sounds very patriotic. Do you have a sin for me today, Kathryn Jean?

K-Lo: It's been kind of quiet lately, Father, so I'm short of sins this week. I'm sorry. Oh! I did covet my neighbor's wife.

Father: Uh, Kathryn Jean, don't you mean husband?

K-Lo: I mean Mrs. McCain, Father. She looked so sad yet strong, and real pretty too. I wanted someone to look at me that way, Father. Sad and resigned, yet always smiling. Like the way Mama looks at Daddy.

Father: I see. Yes, we all long for someone to be close to, but I know you hold Jesus close to your heart and will always turn to him as well. Okay, next sin?

K-Lo: ...

Father: Kathryn Jean?

K-Lo: (rapidly) Father, I gave up on marrying "Mittens." It Was Not To Be, just like in that book I confiscated from a girl on the bus.

Father: Did you take her book, Kathryn Jean?

K-Lo: It was my duty, Father. The cover had pornography on it and it was called "Love's Throbbing Desire."

Father: So then you read it?

K-Lo: It was my--

Father: --Duty, yes.

K-Lo: In the book a girl discovers that her boyfriend is just pretending to be nice when he's really mean and makes fun of her. So she meets another man instead, a dashing naval captain with a mad wife in the tool shed. Then the wife falls on a pitchfork and dies, and the girl and sea captain live happily ever after.

Father: K-Lo, you wouldn't happen to have bought a pitchfork lately, have you?

K-Lo: No Father.

Father: Thank the Lord.

K-Lo: I bought a RonCo earth tiller, as seen on tv. I can just prop it up out of the way during a townhall rally, and let nature take its course.

Father: Kathryn Jean, I think you should come to see me at the Parish hall tomorrow, about 8:oo. A very nice support group for singles meets there, and you can make some friends and learn a little about relationships. I'd also like you to meet a friend of mine, a doctor who specializes in, uh, talking to people with problems.

K-Lo: I appreciate that Father but I need to keep my schedule open until the election. And tomorrow I'm going down to the docks to meet some sailors. Maybe they'll tell me what a sailor likes in a girlfriend.

Father: No doubt, no doubt, my dear. Well, I won't try to argue with you. By the way, could you run to my office and fetch my rosary? I seem to have left it on my desk.

K-Lo: Sure, Father. Uh, shouldn't I say a Hail Mary or two?

Father: Of course, of course. Now run along, dear. (beeping noises) Operation Bernadette is a go. Repeat, Operation Bernadette is a go!

Friday, October 10, 2008

Run Away, Cindy

It deeply grieves me to report that Kathryn Jean Lopez might be a fickle little tramp. After swearing undying love loyalty to "Mittens" Romney, her wandering eyes have lighted upon the unwary John McCain.

I've always thought you can always tell a lot about a campaign through the eyes of the loving wife of the candidate. One Super Tuesday night in Boston, I was feet away from the Romneys as he talked about taking it to the convention. He was telling you the truth, he hadn't decided to drop out yet. But you knew, even if he hadn't made the call yet, that he'd not be in the race by week's end. You could see it in Mrs. Romney's eyes.

Right now I'm watching John McCain in Wisconsin. Cindy McCain has intense worry in her eyes. I wish we could all take the weekend off as a country and come back Monday ready to have a serious election. I bet Mrs. McCain would agree.

That reminds me of a song....

When I look in your eyes,
I see the wisdom of the world in your eyes
I see the sadness of a thousand goodbyes
When I look in your eyes

And it is no surprise,
to see the softness of the moon in your eyes
The gentle sparkle of the stars in your eyes
When I look in your eyes

In your eyes, I see the deepness of the sea
I see the deepness of the love
The love I feel you feel for me

Autumn comes, summer dies
I see the passing of the years in your eyes
And when we part there will be no tears no goodbyes
I'll just look into your eyes

Those eyes, so wise
So warm, so real
How I love the world, your eyes reveal.

Jonah Never Fails

When you're out fishing for snark, it always pays to check out Jonah Goldberg, the man best known for the bottomless depth of his stupidity. He's a mash-up of George Costanza, Otto from A Fish Called Wanda, and The Comic Book Guy from The Simpsons. For example:

I think this reader gets at a good point. If it's time for a new New Deal,
what good was the old one?

Come on. That's not ideology, that's having his head so far up his ass that he can see the back of his eyelids.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

The League of Extraordinary Bloggers

Part I: The Adventure Begins
Part II: A Fresh Face
Part III: And The Band Played On


In a Secret Location, deep beneath the bowels, entrails and colon of Pennsylvania Avenue, a Meeting of Diabolical Minds takes place. It is the League of Extraordinary Bloggers, each a hero (or a heroine or a Coulter) in his (or hers, or Coulter's) own sphere. They are:

Col. Glenn Reynolds—famous defender of guns, wherever they are needed to fight the Brown Menace.

Michelle Malkin—a creature of the night, with an insatiable thirst for blood under her modest, cheerleader-clad façade.

Jonah Goldberg—A barefoot man-boy with cheek, famous for being so lazy he got his research assistant to paint his fence.

Megan McArdle--a woman of mystery, of disguise, of charm, which hides an unscrupulous and greedy heart.

Ann Althouse—A respectable professor who digs deep into the evil aspects of her psyche when she drink an experimental potion know as “Merlot.”



Reynolds: We are here to address the grave danger facing our nation. We are at war with Barack Hussein Obama, and the natives are winning. Get out your instructions.

Everyone unfolds the sheet of paper they are each holding.

Goldberg: I get to read it aloud because I'm the intellectual.

McArdle: I'm better educated than you are, Jonah. My prep school cost--

All: Thirty-eight thousand dollars a year, we know.

McArdle: And I went to Penn and the University of Chicago. That's a lot more expensive than your stupid girls' finishing school.

Goldberg: It's not a finishing school any more, smarty pants. It's a coeducational university and I was a legacy!

Althouse: Glenn and I are law professors. That's a lot better than a business degree. You have to be smart to be a lawyer; my daddy said so.

Malkin rolls her eyes.

McArdle: Did you carry a parasol to class, Jonah? I hear the students all have to wear their hair up in a bun and are just dying to marry well--oh, obviously you *did* learn that one.

Goldberg: At least I did get married. You'd better hurry up because there aren't as many millionaire out there as there used to be and you're almost old enough to be my mom.

McArdle: I'm younger than you are, you moron. And your mom's a million years old.

Goldberg: You stop talking about my mother! Everybody says bad things about my mom and I'm sick of it. Cut it out or I'll call you a fascist!

Malkin: (dryly) You terrify us, Goldilocks. Now shut up before I get hungry.

Goldberg (mutters) I was on the Daily Show and you weren't. I win.

Reynolds: All right, Goldberg. You can read. I hope.

Goldberg: Dear Extraordinary Bloggers. Your mission is to close in for the kill and eliminate Barack Obama. Polling has determined that the following subjects should not be brought up, as they have negative numbers; Iraq, the economy, the ownership society, Wall Street, the dollar, education, infrastructure, car loans, the stock market, New Orleans, and the global economy. Instead, William Ayers must be on the lips of every American consumer by next week. These are desperate times, Bloggers. We're counting on you. Hugs and Kisses, Karl.

Reynolds: I need your very best ideas, Bloggers, and I need them now!

McArdle pulls a daguerreotype from her pocket and passes it to Reynolds.

McArdle: Fellow Bloggers, I have in my possession a photo of Barack Obama with Bill Ayers. As you will see, Ayers has his arms around Obama in a very friendly fashion. We can use it to blackmail Obama into dropping out of the race.

Malkin takes the photo from Reynolds and looks at it.

Malkin: Who's the kid?

McArdle (stiffly) Obama, of course. Don't you know what he looks like?

Goldberg: This could be Michael Jackson for all I know. Hey, maybe we can say that Michael Jackson had more surgeries and now he's That One Known As Barack Obama.

Althouse: How do you speak in capitals like that? I want to speak in capitals too.

McArdle: There could be bomb materials in that "Lost In Space" lunchbox, you know.

Reynolds: Megan, we appreciate the effort but we need a picture of Obama with Ayers as an adult. Do you think you can do that?

McArdle: Sure, I'll just go back to the University of Chicago, where I found it in one of my professor's home office.

Goldberg: What were you doing in your professor's apartment?

McArdle: Networking.

Malkin: Oh, that's what they're calling it now.

McArdle: Shut up, you brown person, you. My classmates and I used to laugh at people like you, with your funny little home-made lunches and out-of-date socks.

Althouse giggles. Megan tosses her hair and smiles. Malkin bursts into tears.

Goldberg: Are you girls going to fight? I can record it and make a fortune.

Reynolds: Jonah, shut up. This is serious. My stock portfolio is dropping, my bonds were hit, and the missus cancelled my subscription to Popular Mechanical Women.

Goldberg: I'm a very serious person, Glenn. I'm a leading intellectual in the conservative movement and everyone wants to shake my hand and buy me a beer, as long as it isn't too expensive. My ideas echo across the blogosphere, and every day more people tell me how smart I am. When's the last time you were on the Daily Show, Glenn?

Reynolds pulls his gun and points it at Jonah's nose. Jonah pees on himself. Malkin smiles through her tears. McArdle wrinkles her nose.

McArdle: You stink, Goldberg.

Malkin: Glenn, you didn't have to buy a new house at the height of the housing bubble. It's worth less every month.

Reyonolds: God only know what's happening to my University of Tennessee Retirement Fund.

McArdle: You should have taken my advice and not looked. If you don't look, you'll never know if you lost money until it's too late to worry about it.

Reynolds: If I had a robot wife she'd never nag me or make me take out the trash or memorize safe words. I want to go home and watch Serenity again.

Althouse: Am I poor too, Glenn? What about shopping in New York and new cameras? And box wine isn't getting any cheaper, you know. This is all Greenspan's fault.

McArdle whirls on Althouse and slaps her. Althouse slaps back and Jonah whips out his camera. Ann bursts into tears. Glen hands her a drink, and then another when the first is swiftly downed.

Althouse:(*sniff*) You're all just indulging in anti-Althousania. You're--you're vortexy and swirley and spinney and rotatey and I think I need to lie down now. Megan, would you care to join me, I mean walk me home?

Reynolds: McArdle, throw her in a cab and get back to Chicago. We're depending on you.

McArdle and Althouse depart.

Reyonold: This Ayers thing will work. It has to. We have nothing to lose.

Goldberg: Tell that to my stock broker. I cracked my wife's password and checked it out. We lost 120 thousand dollars in a couple of months. Now what do I do? A man can't go to his mother for money forever.

Malkin: You mean she cut you off?

Goldberg: (shouting) It was for my own good! My mother loves me!

Malkin snickers and files her fangs.

Reynolds: I don't believe it.

Goldberg: We did too. It was a lot of money and it's going to take a long time before we can inherit more. My wife cut my allowance, and she told me I can't go to San Diego for Comic Con. We had to drive across the Heartland to be with Real Americans instead. I don't want to see real Americans. I want to see goth college girls dressed up like Vampirella.

Reynolds: No you idiot, I don't believe you cracked your wife's password.

Goldberg:(mumbles) I'm smarter than you think. My book is famous and now everyone's calling liberals socialists and saying Hitler was really kind of nice.

Malkin: Let me guess; it was Doughy Pantload.

Goldberg bursts into tears and runs off.

Reyonolds: (sighing) Okay, let's do this thing. I'll link to Ayers stories and you write some op-eds for the Corner. We'll beat those Fuzzy Wuzzys yet.

Malkin changes into a bat and flies off.

Reynolds pulls out a photograph of a beautiful android in a mini-skirt and boots. He sighs again.

Reynolds: This is all Karl's fault.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Little Blessings

I'm not sure why (necrobuckleyphilia?), but the Corner publishes articles by Catholic priests occasionally. They are often about abortion or materialism, and this one's a twofer.

An honest analysis, in the end, will confirm that it is simplistic in the extreme to claim that the current financial meltdown in the United States was simply brought upon us by Wall Street greed. This crisis is, in large part, the result of something much more profuse: a collective chink in our American armor, a flaw in our fabric, a cultural deficit. In the end we have, all of us, built our houses, if not completely, at least partially, on the sand of a materialism, instant gratification, and over-consumption. I don’t believe most people seek money as their ultimate end in life; but the pursuit of comfort and status comes close to that at times and in many ways is even worse. Far too many Americans have built their houses on sand.


An economic crisis like the present means that millions of Americans will experience negative, discomforting and, in many cases, dire consequences. But no expert I know of is suggesting the crisis will reach bread-line proportions. And even it if did, the suffering of such consequences comes nowhere close to the moral gravity of human beings directly targeting and destroying the lives of 50 million unborn babies as has been the case under America’s abortion-on-demand regime.

What is your future and your children's future compared to saving unwanted babies? So what if you are suffering; you have too much anyway, and what about the unborn babies? You deserve to suffer because you're afraid of suffering discomfort which makes you forget about saving the suffering babies.

If I didn't know better I'd say the priests are jealous that God gave the ability to procreate to women and not men, and they will never know the joy and pride and deep connection to one's growing child. Suck it up, dudes. You may wear the skirts but we are God's Chosen.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Priceless

Let's see how Megan McArdle handles the entirely predictable failure of the bailout to get the credit markets moving.

People tend to get fixated on things like major bank sales and the level of the various stock indices.

Well, that was random. Who are these people? "Fixated" is an emotion word, and tells us nothing about who is saying what, and where.

These are important, but they are symptoms, not the main show, which is in the credit markets. Those remain frozen up.Was I wrong to support the bailout?


Wait a second. If Megan supported the bailout to unfreeze the credit markets, of course she was wrong to support the bailout, which was too small.

Was I wrong to support the bailout? Hard to say.


No, it's not. Additionally, quite a few people said it was wrong to support the bailout, because giving more money to the people who lost it in the first place was always a very stupid idea. At the very least someone else could have been brought in to try to clean up the disaster a little. But in Bush's (remember him?) CEO presidency, Wall Street gets the golden parachute and the taxpayer gets a helium balloon.

For one thing, it matters whether the alternative was doing nothing, or doing something better; for sure, it was not a very good design, and the bill that actually passed was worse than the one the House voted down.

That is an excuse; any bailout bill is a bad bailout bill. Why used a strategy that failed in Japan when you can uses a strategy that worked in Sweden?

For another, I was not positive that the bailout would solve things; it's just that it seemed like the best shot.

That's quite true. You said, over and over and over and over, that it was the best shot.

Since I can't compare the current world with some alternative in which it failed again, I need to think about what my metrics for assessing the decision should be.

How about reason and facts instead of emotion and expediency?

The Price

Miss Megan McArdle must be feeling rather rattled right now. Her Brave New Economic World of investment banks, securities, bubbles and regulation-free Randians has come crashing down around her Mossimo-clad ankles. The blogosphere has not been kind lately, and smarter fish have found a new sea in which to swim. What's a highly-paid, almost-but-not-quite-Ivy Leaguer to do?

Borrow material from the low-rent versions of herself.

Yes, McArdle has descended into Michelle Malkin territory, using many many words instead of home-made cheerleader videos, to deplore Barack Obama's connection to Bill Ayers.


[...I]n fact I think that the Ayers connection is too tenuous to be
interesting. But there is a nugget of a real critique at its heart, which
is that the academic culture Obama belongs to thinks its just fine to be a
former active terrorist who has refused to renounce support for the violence
committed by his group; that culture has rewarded Bill Ayers with prestigious
employment and other positions in a way that it wouldn't dream of rewarding a
similarly "idealistic" abortion clinic bomber. I know it's hard to
imagine, but if you're conservative, that seems like a real problem.


Yes, the connection between Obama and Ayers is tenuous, but it allows one to use the word "terrorist" next to Obama's name, and that's enough to earn another paycheck. You see, if you connect Obama with terrorists in the pages of The freaking Atlantic, you can afford weekends at Myrtle Beach, where lonely Republicans with trust funds go to play, or uncomfortable shoes that other women will look at with envy. You can leaf through catalogues of overpriced clothes made by Chinese wage slaves knowing that you can buy anything you want, as long as you charge it. You can linger in the sidewalk cafes, ordering tapas and wine by the glass. It's a good life, and all she has to do is drop a word here, a word there. Tiny little drops of poison, administered slyly to the body politic day after day, to keep the jewels and shoes and catalogues coming.

I'll have more later. Much, much more.

Friday, October 3, 2008

God is Love

I have to work now, so just a link: Arthur Silber.

My imaginary god (unlike everyone else's imaginary god) loves everyone equally. God is Jesus is God, in Christianity. Jesus did not exclude ANYONE from his love. If you hate gays you hate Jesus. If gays squick you out, so does Jesus. He is both human and God, and to hate your fellow man is to hate God. There is no excuse, ever.

And a special note for Megan McArdle: your attitude towards gay marriage would make my Jesus weep with grief and pain. Whatsoever you do to the "least" of My brothers, that you do unto Me.

ADDED: Miss Megan's explanation why gay marriage might affect her own status hetero marriage.

To which social conservatives reply that institutions have a number of complex
ways in which they fulfill their roles, and one of the very important ways in
which the institution of marriage perpetuates itself is by creating a romantic
vision of oneself in marriage that is intrinsically tied into expressing one's
masculinity or femininity in relation to a person of the opposite sex; stepping
into an explicitly gendered role. This may not be true of every single marriage,
and indeed undoubtedly it is untrue in some cases. But it is true of the
culture-wide institution. By changing the explicitly gendered nature of marriage
we might be accidentally cutting away something that turns out to be a crucial
underpinning.

To which, again, the other side replies "That's
ridiculous! I would never change my willingness to get married based on whether
or not gay people were getting married!"

Now, economists hear this sort
of argument all the time. "That's ridiculous! I would never start working fewer
hours because my taxes went up!" This ignores the fact that you may not be the
marginal case. The marginal case may be some consultant who just can't justify
sacrificing valuable leisure for a new project when he's only making 60 cents on
the dollar. The result will nonetheless be the same: less economic activity.
Similarly, you--highly educated, firmly socialised, upper middle class you--may
not be the marginal marriage candidate; it may be some high school dropout in
Tuscaloosa. That doesn't mean that the institution of marriage won't be weakened
in America just the same.


You see, if some teenage bigot in Tuscaloosa, Alabama says, "Damn, them gays are gettin' married? That's disgustin'. That settles it, Tiffany. You may be knocked up but we ain't gettin' married now!" then society will fall and Megan's potential marriage might lose some of its status as Extra Special Holy Pageantry Day of Me. So, no marriage for you! Just marriage for Megan, who deserves it because she was born straight. If you are born gay, forget it, you're not good enough. Or at least not good enough for Megan.

UPDATE: Unfortunately Megan's link no longer works. Try http://www.janegalt.net/blog/archives/005244.html

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Let Palin Be Palin

I'll say it again; every time Palin opens her mouth, she reveals that she's a true Republican, gullible and authoritarian and so self-deluded that she routinely makes major campaigning mistakes in public.

From Think Progress:

I have, one of my absolute best friends for the last 30 years who happens
to be gay. And I love her dearly. And she is not my “gay friend.” She is one of
my best friends who happens to have made a choice that isn’t a choice that I
have made. But I am not gonna judge people. And I love America where we are more tolerant than other countries are. And are more accepting of some of these
choices that sometimes people want to believe reflects solely on an individual’s
values or not. Homosexuality, I am not gonna judge people.


She is trying to say the right thing the right way but can't, because she actually believes what she is saying. Instead of sounding sincere but non-committal, using dog-whistle words instead of frank acknowledgement of wingnut positions, she repeats what she's been told in fundamentalist circles. We are letting Palin be Palin, and it's a disaster.

Moderates don't want to hear about judging gays or choosing orientation. Fundamentalists don't want to hear about acceptance. Gays don't want to hear about more straights who judge them on their love life. Foreigners don't want to hear about how tolerant we are. And of course liberals in general don't want this fundamentalist anywhere near our beloved Constitution.

Our elite despises the Heartland fundamentalists; that's why they accuse the other side of doing the same thing so vociferously. The poor go to ugly churches and wear cheap clothes and have teeth and hair that don't shine as brightly as the elite's. They don't go to dinner parties and drink expensive wine and call important people by their first names. They are Other, and the elite--which is neither Democratic nor Republican, it is just very rich--hate them.

John McCain made a very, very big mistake.

Why did this fool choose Palin? I think that McCain, who almost entirely owes his career to luck, privilege, rank and expediency, chose the woman who would reflect best upon himself. He actually picked the prettiest girl in the room to stand by his side, so he'd be the BMOC. He could have picked one of a dozen older, less attractive conservative women to become vice-president. It's utterly astonishing in its vanity, hubris and disregard for country, party and colleagues. He's going to make DC and New York bow down before a lower-class young beauty queen from the hicks with no commiserate qualifications. Palin will sit in Dick Cheney's office with Dick Cheney's laws and Dick Cheney's budget and Dick Cheney's personnel, and there is nothing that will be able to stop her.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Megan Explains Her Modus Operandi

It's a lot easier to bluff, because the odds are that mistakes won't be caught.

And if they are, you can just ignore the corrections or tell the critic he "misunderstands."

Theater Burlesque

Megan is workin' it like an ecdysiast, an old-timey one with giant fans that snap open and shut, or balloons that are teasingly popped one by one. It's smoke and mirrors, to use yet another metaphor (which would annoy Megan immensely).

Megan, who did not mind the inventive methods used to create a shadow baking system without oversight, now is incensed that the people who lost billions might not get more billions. She seems to think that if the government doesn't get what it wants, right now, without oversight or limit, the financial system will collapse. And the people who stood in the way to obey their constituents, as the House Republicans did, "deserves to be tried for treason."

"We clearly need better regulations," Megan said, now that the negative effect of no regulation has become too clear to be denied. However, Megan continues to mitigate the damage done by Republican policies, her real job. The SEC was not lax, bank runs are complicated, there was no single cause-- anything to divert the reader from thinking about regulation further.

She goes on and on, but it would be too tedious to report in detail. Politicians are disgusting, dissenting Republicans are whiners, Nancy Pelosi is a screw-up, the successful Swedish model with no bailouts wouldn't work here, the bailout wasn't sold well, ignorant people should shut up about the bailout, McCain didn't really want a bailout. No fewer than ten posts by the world's laziest econoblogger. It's a torrent of output by her standards; she must be under a lot of pressure to support the wants of the rich.

Monday, September 29, 2008

Anatomy of Hack At Work

A hack has two concurrent jobs; to push untruths on the people and to mitigate truths. Megan mitigates the truth in this post, diverting attention from her own bad advice and the machinations of her heroes on Wall Street.


A journalist friend who spends way more time on politics than I do suggests that if the Democrats cave and include a capital gains tax, it will probably pass--but puts the odds of the Democrats caving at slim to none, since they can now blame any resulting crash on the Republicans.

I didn't think it was possible to be more disgusted with politicians than I usually am, but I find it impossible to express the seething contempt that I feel at this kind of opportunism. I don't mind when they screw with the normal operation of the economy for venal personal gain. But risking a recession in order to get a cut in the capital gains tax? Letting it tank because you can always blame it on the Republicans?


The Democratic politicians betrayed their constituents with their bought-and-paid-for complicity, but the Republicans actually obeyed their constituents. They removed regulation safeguards and lowered taxes for the rich. They let a shadow banking system grow up that made a relatively few people incredibly rich. Greenspan, Paulson, Bernanke--all helped the White House let Wall Street run wild and free. And "libertarian" Megan McArdle cheered them on, constantly applauding the end of regulation and supporting bad decisions that violated common sense. Naturally she hemmed and hawed, adding enough caveats and warnings, as well as lies and evasions, to cover her rear if she erred out of bad judgement or ignorance.

Megan, who believes that the more money you have the more moral you must be, despises teachers, food stamp recipients, the ill and handicapped, and many other people not fortunate enough to be born in relative affluence. Because she despises them she assumes the worst of them. Likewise, Megan despises liberals, for whatever inexplicable reason that cankers her soul. So anything liberals do must be immoral and despicable. If liberals don't vote for a bill that they feel will not solve the problem and will unfairly be financed by the taxpayer, well, Megan feels (not thinks, feels) that they are doing it out of spite. It is something she understands, after all.

Liberals also own stock, run companies, and of course have a stake in the well-being of their own country, where they are raising their children and where their ancestors were born and died. But out of personal spite and immorality, as well as practical job considerations, Megan writes a foolish and inaccurate post that indulges in spite while not adding anything to the public discourse.

However, Megan is also insulting Republicans, saying they'll tank the bargain to get a capital gains tax cut. Most Republicans voting against the bailout seem to be listening to their constituents, with an eye on coming elections. A few others are acting out of genuine ideological principle. Either way, they are doing what they think they should do. It doesn't necessarily follow that they just want lower taxes. No Republican will miss a chance to try to screw the Democratic Party over when an important bill comes up; they can't help it.

So by attacking both parties, Megan is trying to divert blame from the country's economic policies, many of which she enthusiastically supported. (More or less.) In other words, Megan sneers and insults and is filled with "seething contempt," but mostly she covers her own expensively upholstered ass.

spelling error corrected

No Megan This Morning

Unfortuantely, due to the poor work ethic of Ms. McArdle (or perhaps a hangover, who knows) I cannot provide any Megan moments. No doubt she will make up for it later, with posts that would make Jesus weep in despair.

Speaking of Jesus, let's see what he has to say about the rich and poor.


Unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required: and to whom men have committed much, of him they will ask the more.

A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another. By this shall all men know that ye are my disciples, if ye have love one to another.

It is more blessed to give than to receive.

The House Always Wins

Superstitious folk like to say that the most clever thing the Devil ever did was convince the world he didn't exist. That's not true on many levels, but the basic principle does work: Get people to argue about irrelevant details and they will totally overlook the big picture.

We should not be bailing out Wall Street. Giving more money to the people who already lost billions is the height of stupidity. Liberals are arguing with great passion about the details of the bailout, hoping to "win" by putting their slant on it, but they are not saying that the bailout mustn't happen. If you are arguing on the other side's terms, you have already lost.

From Angry Bear:

Joseph Stilgitz asks tough questions at The Nation:

The champagne bottle corks were popping as Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson announced his trillion-dollar bailout for the banks, buying up their toxic mortgages. To a skeptic, Paulson's proposal looks like another of those shell games that Wall Street has honed to a fine art. Wall Street has always made money by slicing, dicing and recombining risk. This "cure" is another one of these rearrangements: somehow, by stripping out the bad assets from the banks and paying fair market value for them, the value of the banks will soar.

There is, however, an alternative explanation for Wall Street's celebration: the banks realized that they were about to get a free ride at taxpayers' expense. No private firm was willing to buy these toxic mortgages at what the seller thought was a reasonable price; they finally had found a sucker who would take them off their hands--called the American taxpayer.


The Bonddad Blog:

This isn't too hard people. If you're going to do this you should set a few basic guidelines. One -- those who made really stupid decisions in buying this paper without analyzing it should not be able to dump it at an above market rate. Letting them do so subsidizing that mistake on the backs of taxpayers.


Michael Hudson, former Wall Street Economist:

What it can do is provide a one-time transfer of wealth to insiders who already have been playing the debt-credit system and siphoning off its predatory financial proceeds to themselves. The Wall Street bankers, brokers and fund managers to whom I’ve been speaking for many decades all know this. That is why they pay themselves such large annual bonuses and large salaries each year. The idea is to take as much as you can. As the saying goes: “You only have to make a fortune once in a lifetime.” They have been salting away their fortunes year after year, mainly in hard assets: real estate (free of mortgages), fine furniture, boats and trophy art. One last $700 billion heist and they can make their getaway.


Naomi Klein:

What Gingrich's wish list tells us is that the dumping of private debt into the public coffers is only stage one of the current shock. The second comes when the debt crisis currently being created by this bailout becomes the excuse to privatize social security, lower corporate taxes and cut spending on the poor. A President McCain would embrace these policies willingly. A President Obama would come under huge pressure from the think tanks and the corporate media to abandon his campaign promises and embrace austerity and "free-market stimulus."

We have seen this many times before, in this country and around the world. But here's the thing: these opportunistic tactics can only work if we let them. They work when we respond to crisis by regressing, wanting to believe in "strong leaders" - even if they are the same strong leaders who used the September 11 attacks to push through the Patriot Act and launch the illegal war in Iraq.

So let's be absolutely clear: there are no saviors who are going to look out for us in this crisis. Certainly not Henry Paulson, former CEO of Goldman Sachs, one of the companies that will benefit most from his proposed bailout (which is actually a stick up). The only hope of preventing another dose of shock politics is loud, organized grassroots pressure on all political parties: they have to know right now that after seven years of Bush, Americans are becoming shock resistant.


But we aren't. We'll do what we're told, close our eyes, and hope for the best. We will do nothing to save ourselves, because to do that will be to admit that Americans are not the best and brightest, our ideals are a thin veneer created to hide the greed and naked callousness of our ruling class, and, at long last, we can no longer force others to suffer so we that can prosper.

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Mortgages of Mass Destruction





Senator Dianne Feinstein, via Mish's Global Economic Trends:


Since this announcement, my offices have received thousands of comments
from Californians like you concerned about how this action will affect them.
Yet, I believe prudent action must be taken. The bill should include the
following principles: a phase-in of funding; oversight, accountability and
transparency; a mechanism allowing the Secretary of the Treasury to modify
mortgages to prevent additional foreclosures; and a precise cap on executive
compensation.

The current credit crisis affects all Americans. If action is not taken to
stem the crisis, Americans risk losing their homes, jobs, personal savings, life
insurance and more. Banks will cease to lend to businesses and homeowners, and
credit will be increasingly difficult to come by for average Americans. I
strongly believe that the consequences of failing to act now would be greater
than not acting at all.

The Sexual Drawback of Palin's Run

Aimai links to a fascinating article in the Huffington Post about alpha male behavior in primates and the body language of the candidates in the presidential debates. This sentence was especially interesting to me because it explained something that was bothering me in the back of my mind. It instinctively seemed to me that it was a bad idea to have a youngish woman run for office with McCain and the author, Frans de Waal, points out why:
Seeing an older male paired with a much younger female sets off red flags
in the heads of many women, so that for McCain and Palin to appear side-by-side
may be problematic.

It's especially bad for McCain, since he openly admits that he dumped his badly injured wife for a healthy, young, fertile, rich one. If he had lied about his running around it would be different; all the conservatives want is a comforting lie, but in his arrogance he didn't. So now the philandering male appears by the side of the attractive youngish woman who reproduced just this year.

The McCain camp correctly assumed that the Republicans would be happy to have an attractive woman as a candidate. But because of her baby and her daughter's pregnancy, the sexuality of Palin's public image is very strong. The Republican men are excited to have an attractive woman to look at after years of "Dick" Cheney and many are raised to be traditional and see women primarily as sex objects. The women have learned that if they are attractive and of reproductive age (and therefore suitable subjects for male fantasies), they will be able to advance in their conservative careers more easily than otherwise. Thus we have Ann Coulter and Michelle Malkin.

But there is a very serious potential drawback, as de Waal notes. Because conservative women are so strongly encouraged/coerced to adopt traditional roles of dependence and submission, they also must deal with the fears that come with them. A dependent woman must constantly worry that she will be abandoned for someone her husband, the sole bread-winner, finds more attractive. Seeing the philandering McCain next to the attractive, sexual Palin rings some very distressing bells for a lot of conservative women.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Jonah Goldberg Has a Request

Jonah Goldberg is preparing the paperback edition of his book "Liberal Fascism: From Lucianne's Pocketbook to Wingnut Welfare," and he continues his fine tradition of not actually doing very much work. He has admitted that he didn't read all of the books he used for research from beginning to end, and just cherry-picked the bits he wanted. He also blegged extensively for help in finding and understanding the reading material. When after four years he still hadn't finished his book, he hired an assistant. Finally it was published and now the paperback is going to be printed.

But Jonah has one more request.

Favor from Readers

The paperback is coming in the spring and in addition
to a new post-election chapter I need to provide the publisher with a list of
fixes for typographical and other discrete errors. I can't do wholesale
revisions. But if I got a date wrong, misspelled a name, etc. I can make those
sorts of fixes. I have a few. But if you can recall others, please send them
along to me with the subject header "revision." Thanks!


And we are supposed to take conservative intellectuals seriously?

Jonah Goldberg--the comedy gift that keeps on giving.

Flashback Megan: Obesity

In its entirety:

Why not food stamps?

1) The poor don't need more food. Obesity is a problem for the poor in
America; except for people who are too screwed up to get food stamps (because
they don't have an address), food insufficiency is not.
2) Food stamps only imperfectly translate into increased cash income, meaning that the poor will spend . . . more money on food.
3) If the increase in food stamps takes the
form of expanded eligibility, rather than larger grants, the administrative
issues and public outreach will delay your stimulus until well after it is no
longer needed.
4) The limits on the type of goods available to food stamp
consumers, and the growing season, mean that some (it's hard to say how much) of
the food stamp spending will simply draw down perishable stocks rather than
generating new economic activity. Eventually this will probably generate more
economic activity, but probably well after your stimulus is needed.
5) The economy doesn't need a food sector more distorted by daft government programs than it already is. If you want to give money to the poor, give it to them. Even if they spend it all on drugs, it will hardly be much worse than spending it all
on increasing their already astronomical obesity rates.


You see, the problem with the poor is that they are too fat, and if you give them food stamps they'll buy food and just get fatter. So don't give food stamps to families so they can feed their children; the kids are too fat anyway. What's that? You'd like evidence? Silly people, don't you know Megan went to a private prep school? That's all the evidence you'll ever need.

I'm not sure what she's trying to say with #4. The USDA lists the following as eligible food items:


Foods for the household to eat, such as:

breads and cereals;
fruits and vegetables;
meats, fish and poultry;
and dairy products.

Seeds and plants which produce food for the household to eat.


That's a pretty wide variety of foodstuffs. Considering all the food issues Megan has (she is constantly discussing what she will and will not eat and how giving up food is morally superior), I have a feeling Megan, a former Catholic, does not look at food as nutrition. Instead it's a way to reward and punish people, and an indication of worthiness.

Flashback Megan: Creationism

I don't know how willing I am to ratify the scientific assumption that the
supernatural is never a possible explanation. I am a radical skeptic;
I think that the supernatural is generally a very unlikely explanation, but
I can evince no proof that the laws of physics as generally observed operate always
and everywhere.

Nor do I think that even Young Earth creationism can be ruled out by science, if you are willing to posit the possibility of a creator; God might have created the world looking old for His own inscrutable reasons.

She has to make mealy-mouthed caveats because she can't bring herself to have an opinion that might harm her financial prospects.

Flashback Megan: Bubble Economies

But I don't think that the world would have been a happier place if Greenspan had
kept the lid on the punchbowl in 1998 and 2002. We haven't had a really bad,
deep recession in 26 years, and it seems reasonable to think that the Fed's
willingness to control inflation, while releasing liquidity as necessary, are
very much responsible for that change. Had Greenspan not opened the taps when
times got tough and markets were unhappy, we might well have had some really
nasty fallout.


Thank God Greenspan made sure the bubble economy lasted! Otherwise we'd have some really nasty fallout. Thank goodness we have an expert like Megan McArdle to guide us.

How The Conservatives See Palin




She's a living doll, on sale now! Get her while she's hot!

Why have a vice-presidental candidate go on television to push his party's message when you can do a meet-and-greet in a Philly bar without discussing anything of substance at all?

We've gone from conservatives lauding "Dick" Cheney as the grown-up in the room with experience and knowledge to a schoolgirl pin-up with a fur collar and hunting rifle.